Skip to content

How to Audit Your Own Public Voice in an Afternoon

A four-hour audit to find the claims you own, the ones your competitors share, and what to say next.

Contents
  1. Why you test against a competitor's CEO
  2. What you need before you start
  3. Hour one: pull everything
  4. Hour two: tag topic and claim
  5. Hour three: run the competitor test
  6. Hour four: count
  7. What to do with the results
  8. Habits that keep your number down
  9. Do it again in twelve months

You can find out in four hours whether anything you said in public last year belonged to you. You pull every post, podcast and talk from the past twelve months into one spreadsheet. You tag each piece by topic and by claim. Then you mark every claim a competitor's CEO could have said without changing a word; then you count them.

Buyers, investors and journalists read and hear what you put out. When they can't tell your claims from your competitor's, they choose between you on price, on headcount or on whoever they met last. When you own a claim, they remember you by it. They repeat it to their colleagues. They book you because of it.

You can run this audit yourself. You need a spreadsheet, a free afternoon and a willingness to read your own posts back honestly.

Why you test against a competitor's CEO

You could test your claims against the whole internet, but your buyers don't. They compare you to the two or three companies on their shortlist. If the CEO of one of those companies could post your line, your buyer learns nothing about you from reading it.

You also make the test easy to run. You don't have to guess whether a claim sounds original in some general sense. You open three feeds and check.

What you need before you start

  • A spreadsheet with six columns: date, channel, link, topic, claim, competitor test.
  • A transcription tool. You can use Descript, Otter or OpenAI's Whisper to turn a podcast episode into text in a few minutes.
  • The names of two or three competitors' CEOs. Pick the ones your buyers compare you to, not the ones you'd like them to compare you to.
  • Four hours with your phone in another room.

Hour one: pull everything

Start with the channels you control. Scroll back or export from LinkedIn, X, your blog, your newsletter and any company posts that carry your name. Paste one row per piece. If you posted a thread, count the thread as one piece.

Then go after the channels you don't control. Search your name on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and Listen Notes to find every episode you guested on. Search YouTube for your conference talks and panels. Search Google News for interviews and press quotes. Search your sent mail for "op-ed" and "byline" to catch pieces you forgot you wrote.

Transcribe the audio and video. You don't need clean transcripts; you need enough text to find what you said.

Include the posts you'd rather forget. If you leave them out, you'll audit the version of yourself you wish you were; you'll learn nothing.

By the end of the hour you should have anywhere from a few dozen rows to a few hundred. If you posted most weeks and did a podcast a month, expect the high end.

Hour two: tag topic and claim

Give each row a topic in two to four words: "AI pricing", "remote hiring", "founder burnout", "category creation". Keep a short list and reuse it. If you end up with sixty topics, merge them until you have ten or fewer.

Then write the claim. Write the one sentence you asserted, in plain words, as if a stranger had asked you, "So what's your point?" Write it as a statement someone could disagree with.

A few examples:

  • Topic: AI pricing. Claim: "Seat-based pricing will die within three years because agents don't need seats."
  • Topic: hiring. Claim: "Great teams beat great ideas."
  • Topic: fundraising. Claim: "Founders should raise less than they think they need."

You'll find plenty of rows with no claim at all: product announcements, "excited to share" posts, congratulations to partners, podcast episodes where you told your origin story for forty minutes. Tag those "no claim" and move on. You'll count them later.

Be strict about one rule here. Write down what you said, not what you meant to say. If you meant "seat-based pricing is dying" but you said "the future of pricing is evolving", you write down "the future of pricing is evolving". Your readers only got the second version.

Hour three: run the competitor test

Open the feeds of the CEOs you picked. For each claim in your sheet, ask one question: could one of these people have posted this sentence without changing a word?

Mark each claim one of three ways:

  • Theirs too. Any of them could have said it. "Customer obsession wins." "AI will change how every team works." "Founders should raise less than they think they need."
  • Contested. One of them might say it, but at least one would argue against it.
  • Yours. None of them would say it; you could defend it in a room full of people who disagree.

Search before you guess. Type the key words of your claim into X or LinkedIn search alongside each competitor's name. You may find that a rival posted your line, in nearly the same words, a month before you did. Mark it "theirs too" even if you thought of it first. Your buyers don't care who thought of it first.

Then run a second test on anything you marked "yours". Ask whether a sensible person would argue the opposite. Nobody argues that customers deserve worse service, or that hiring bad people is fine. If nobody would take the other side, you stated a value everyone holds. Mark it "theirs too".

You probably won't enjoy this hour. Founders who post a lot often discover they spent the year agreeing with their competitors in public.

Hour four: count

Add up four numbers:

  1. Total pieces.
  2. Pieces with no claim.
  3. Claims marked "theirs too".
  4. Claims marked "yours".

Divide your "theirs too" claims by your total claims. I call that figure your interchangeable rate. Write it at the top of the sheet.

Then sort by topic and look at where your "yours" claims sit. You'll usually find them in narrow areas where you've done the work: a pricing model you rebuilt, a market you sold into for years, a hiring process you scrapped and rebuilt. You'll usually find your "theirs too" claims in broad areas you talk about because everyone else does: AI, leadership, the economy, the future of work.

Last, compare your "no claim" count to your total. If half your output had no claim, you spent half your time in public saying nothing anyone could quote back to you.

What to do with the results

Keep the "yours" claims. Copy them into a separate doc. You now have a list of positions you can build a year of content on.

Build next quarter around the three strongest. Pick the three you'd defend hardest. Write a long post on each one. Pitch each one to podcast hosts as the reason to book you; hosts look for guests who will say something their last guest didn't. Open your next talk with one of them.

Sharpen or drop the "theirs too" claims. For each one, ask what you believe about the topic that your competitors don't. If you can't answer, stop posting about that topic. If you can, rewrite the claim until none of your competitors could post it.

Treat "contested" claims as your best material for the next six months. When at least one rival would argue with you, you have a debate you can start in public. People share arguments far more than they share agreement. You also force your competitors to respond to you; their audiences then hear your argument in your words.

Cut back on "no claim" posts. You'll still announce launches and thank partners. Set yourself a rule: for every post with no claim, you publish one with a claim you own.

Decide your claims before you speak. Before your next podcast or panel, write the two claims you plan to make on an index card. Bring them up whether or not the host asks. Hosts and moderators steer guests toward safe, general answers; you steer back.

Habits that keep your number down

Once you've run the audit, you can keep the sheet open and add a row every time you publish. You'll spend thirty seconds per post. You'll catch "theirs too" claims before your readers see them.

You can also run the competitor test before you post instead of after. Read your draft, picture each rival CEO's name under it, and ask whether anyone would notice the swap. If nobody would, rewrite the draft or don't post it.

Ask one blunt friend to check your list of "yours" claims. Founders tend to mark their own claims generously. A friend who doesn't work in your market will tell you which of your claims sound like every other founder's.

Do it again in twelve months

Put a date in your calendar a year from today. Run the same audit against the same competitors. You want to see your interchangeable rate fall and your list of "yours" claims grow.

If the rate goes up, sort by topic again. You'll probably find that you started posting about whatever everyone else was posting about that year, and that you borrowed their claims along with their topics. Drop those topics, go back to the claims you own, and run the audit again in six months instead of twelve.

Keep reading.

  1. The marketer's job is the loop: five GTM loops you can build this week

    Five practical GTM loops for finding buyers, starting conversations, creating content and learning from lost deals.

    JA Westenberg23 min read
  2. Why Every Tech Founder Needs a Crisis Comms Plan (And Why 9 out of 10 Don't Have One)

    Your worst day is the wrong time to decide what to say. Build the plan before you need it.

    JA Westenberg8 min read
  3. The State of SaaS GTM: 2027

    How software companies market and sell in B2C, B2P, B2B bottom-up and B2B top-down, and how AI search changes each one.

    JA Westenberg77 min read
  4. Three Marketers and an Infinite Compute Budget

    Keep the people with taste. Give them the tools. Rebuild the marketing department around judgment.

    JA Westenberg9 min read
  5. Railway’s Breach Was Also a Communications Failure

    The engineering response and the communications response are different jobs. Railway’s October 21 incident shows what happens when nobody owns the words.

    JA Westenberg8 min read
  6. The Retainer Teardown

    I took a $2M holding-company retainer apart line by line and rebuilt the same scope with one senior operator and four agents. It costs 6.8% of the fee.

    JA Westenberg17 min read
  7. Asabiyyah

    Ibn Khaldun wrote the best account we have of why groups cohere and why they come apart. It was never about loyalty.

    JA Westenberg9 min read
  8. The State of SaaS GTM

    The old playbook now works against you. A diagnosis of the channels that broke, then the seven motions that still compound.

    JA Westenberg125 min read

Ready to move first?

Work with me

or email hello@thisisstudioself.com

Expect a reply within 24 hours.